Field note 38 of 74 IN THE KITCHEN
Same wheat, different food
Why our house rule is sourdough yes, pasta no, and the one question to ask a baker.
Modern Savage

Sourdough and pasta start life as the same thing: wheat and water. In our house one is in and one is out, and it's the rule people argue with us about most. Fair enough. Here's the thinking.
Sourdough is fermented. Flour and water sit for hours or days while wild yeast and bacteria work through them, and people have made bread that way for thousands of years. Pasta is milled, extruded and dried, with nothing fermented about it.
So our test was never carbohydrate against no carbohydrate. It's whether a process replaced a tradition. Potatoes and white rice pass for the same reason: simple, old, one ingredient. Bread from a bag that lasts a fortnight is a different food wearing the same name.
Try this: the sourdough test at the counter
Buy your loaf from someone who actually baked it.
Ask how long it took: twenty-four hours, or two? A real baker will be pleased you asked.
Read the ingredients. Real sourdough is short: flour, water, salt.
If the list is long, it's ordinary bread with an accent.
Our pouch has a longer list than a loaf. Organs, dates and eight berries, dried and powdered, with every ingredient printed on the back.
